Is Buying a Home Still the American Dream or Just a Nightmare
Is Buying a Home Still the American Dream
or Just a Nightmare?
There’s a growing narrative in media these days: You’ll never buy a house. Headlines scream that homes are unaffordable, owning property is a trap, and the dream of homeownership is out of reach for younger generations. Some even suggest giving up the idea altogether and sticking to renting forever. But is this doomsday talk rooted in fact, or is it just a mix of clickbait and hidden agendas?
Let’s break this down, focusing on some of the common arguments against homeownership and what it might mean for you.
The Case Against Buying a Home: Grant Cardone’s Viewpoint
One of the loudest voices against homeownership is Grant Cardone. Cardone is a well-known entrepreneur and social media personality with a knack for making money (and getting attention). He advises against owning your home, calling it a “trap” and a “nightmare.” Instead, he encourages people to rent the homes they live in and invest their money elsewhere—specifically, with his company, Cardone Capital, which buys apartment buildings and rents them out.
Let’s be clear: Cardone’s business thrives on people choosing to rent. He’s a landlord, and landlords need tenants. This is where his messaging deserves scrutiny because while he discourages people from owning homes, he’s actively building wealth by owning property himself. Let’s unpack his main arguments.
Argument 1: High Insurance Costs
Cardone’s first argument is that high insurance costs make homeownership less appealing. On the surface, this might sound reasonable. Insurance on a home can be expensive, especially in areas prone to natural disasters like Florida. But here’s the thing—a landlord doesn’t absorb those costs out of goodwill; they pass them on to their tenants through rent hikes.
If you’re renting, you’re still paying for those high insurance premiums. The difference? You’re paying for someone else’s investment instead of your own. Whether you own or rent, that cost is baked into your monthly expenses. And if you’re budgeting wisely, homeownership can actually put you in a better long-term position by building equity over time.
Argument 2: Maintenance and Repairs
Another criticism from Cardone is the cost of maintaining a home. Yes, owning a home means unexpected repairs. A broken water heater or leaky roof can hit your wallet hard. But let’s be real—if you’re renting, are landlords always prompt about fixing things?
Not always.
Many renters deal with unresponsive property management companies or landlords who delay maintenance for months.
When you own your home, you’re in control. You decide when and how to handle repairs, and over time, you learn to budget for these expenses.
If you’re renting, you’re still indirectly paying for those maintenance costs through rent increases. Landlords aren’t running charities—they’re running businesses.
Argument 3: Lack of Flexibility
Cardone points out that owning a home ties you down geographically, which limits your ability to move for work or other opportunities. This is a valid concern, especially for people with careers that require frequent relocation.
But here’s a nuance often missed: owning a home doesn’t mean you’re trapped. Many homeowners invest with flexibility in mind. If you know you might need to relocate in a few years, you can look for properties in areas where home values are likely to appreciate or ensure the home can be rented out to cover the mortgage. Over time, many properties begin to cash flow, setting you up for financial stability even after you’ve moved on.
Argument 4: Financial Risks and Fluctuating Property Values
Some argue that tying your mortgage to fluctuating property values is risky. This is only true if you go for risky loans like adjustable-rate mortgages or balloon loans, which are not advisable for most buyers. But with a 30-year fixed mortgage, your payment stays consistent regardless of property value changes.
Think of your home as a long-term investment, not a short-term gamble. If the housing market dips temporarily, it doesn’t matter unless you’re planning to sell soon. Over 5, 10, or 15 years, history shows that property values tend to rise, and you’ll still have built equity along the way.
Argument 5: Unexpected Expenses
There’s no denying it—when you own a home, unexpected expenses can arise. A broken air conditioner, a backed-up sewer line—it’s part of the deal. But here’s a solution: plan ahead. When buying a home, get a thorough inspection so you understand its condition. Then, rebuild your savings after the purchase to prepare for any future surprises.
No one likes unexpected costs, but they’re part of life whether you own or rent. Owning just means having more control and, in the long run, more financial security.
The Billionaire Argument: Why It’s Misleading
Cardone often references billionaires like Elon Musk or Warren Buffett, who either reportedly avoid homeownership or don’t prioritize it. But this argument is out of touch for the average person. A billionaire doesn’t need to worry about having a roof over their head. For most of us, a home isn’t just an expense. It’s a place to live while also potentially building wealth over time.
The analogy that sums it up best? You can’t sleep in your stock portfolio. Owning a home does more than provide financial benefits—it gives you stability, security, and peace of mind, things no stock investment can offer.
Why This Argument Is Really About You
At the end of the day, Cardone’s advice works well for his financial model, but it might not work for you. Homeownership isn’t perfect—it comes with costs, responsibilities, and complexities. But it also builds wealth, provides stability, and gives you something a rental never will: control.
Renting might make sense for some situations, like frequent moves or uncertain career paths. But for many, owning is still a smart way to gain financial security. It’s all about knowing your specific needs, goals, and financial situation.
Conclusion
While media narratives can paint homeownership as unattainable or even undesirable, the truth is more nuanced. Renting may offer short-term convenience, but owning provides long-term benefits that renting simply can’t. Grant Cardone has built his empire on owning property while encouraging others to rent—don’t let his advice derail your dreams unless it truly fits your circumstances.
So, what’s the takeaway? Educate yourself. Run the numbers. Look at your unique situation.
At the end of the day, homeownership isn’t just about dollars and cents—it’s about creating a foundation for your future. If it fits your goals, don’t let fear-mongering or flashy headlines convince you otherwise.
You deserve to pursue what’s best for you.
Jennifer Beeston
SVP Mortgage Lending @ Guaranteed Rate
Phone: 786-933-2077
Apply For Mortgage: www.zerostressmortgage.com
Resources To Learn More:
Youtube Thousands of Mortgage and Real Estate videos: www.youtube.com/jenniferbeeston
Free VA Loan Course: www.nostressva.com
Book Your Mortgage Consultation Now
Ready to take the next step towards your dream home? Book a consultation with Jennifer Beeston today!
Whether you're a first-time buyer or looking to refinance, Jennifer is here to guide you through the process with ease and clarity.
